By Lindia Fazio
People sometimes speak as though cannabis legalization settled the questions patients had been asking for years. It did not. Patients still need reliable information, safe choices, and a healthcare system that listens to them. On Six Nations, we also have to ask who gets to shape the future of medical cannabis in our community.
I believe Six Nations should have the authority to govern both medical cannabis services and recreational dispensaries on our reserve lands, without outside governments dictating every decision. This is about community self-determination as well as responsible access to cannabis. Patients need clear information and the freedom to make informed decisions with their healthcare providers. They need to understand that different preparations can take effect differently, that strength matters, and that starting with a low amount and going slowly can help reduce unwanted effects. No one should be promised that cannabis will work the same way for everyone.
Any medical cannabis service should be accountable to the people it serves. Patient education, careful use, honest information, and community well-being should come before volume or profit. These are responsibilities a community can take seriously and shape for itself.
Self-determination comes with responsibility
Decisions about our community should not be made for us by governments that do not answer to our people. Six Nations has its own history, laws, relationships, and responsibilities. Our community should have a meaningful role in deciding how medical cannabis is approached here.
Self-determination does not mean ignoring patient safety. It means that our people should be able to develop standards and accountability rooted in our own community, values, and experience. Education, transparency, and safeguards can belong in a Six Nations-led approach. They do not have to depend on outside control of every part of community life.
The treaty question deserves careful treatment. Our treaties and inherent rights are part of an ongoing relationship with the Crown, not a slogan or a shortcut around difficult legal questions. Any argument about those rights has to be grounded in Six Nations’ own history, evidence, and legal advice. I am not claiming that a court has established a blanket exemption for cannabis businesses on Six Nations.
A recent Ontario case makes the legal landscape especially important to describe accurately. In R. v. Plain, 2026 ONSC 63, Justice Raikes rejected treaty and Aboriginal-rights arguments made by members of Aamjiwnaang and Chippewas of Kettle and Stony Point who were operating unlicensed commercial cannabis stores. The decision was released on January 5, 2026, and turned on the evidence and legal arguments in that case; it did not decide Six Nations’ specific history or record.
Justice Raikes also discussed Ontario’s existing Cannabis Control Act. Section 43 allows the province to make agreements with a First Nation band council about cannabis sales on reserve, including licensing and regulation. The judgment noted that the applicants had not challenged the Ontario law or shown that they had applied for, or could not obtain, a licence. This is a route that operates within provincial and federal rules; it is not the same as recognizing a community’s independent authority to make its own cannabis law.
In 2024, the Nova Scotia Provincial Court rejected the Aboriginal and treaty-rights defence presented in R. v. Marshall et al., 2024 NSPC 33. However, on October 29, 2026, the Nova Scotia Supreme Court overturned Darren Marshall’s convictions and ordered a new trial because he had been denied a fair opportunity to present his defence. This is an important distinction: the earlier decision had been used in arguments against Indigenous cannabis rights, yet Marshall’s convictions were subsequently overturned because his trial was unfair. The appeal did not establish a general treaty right to sell cannabis, but it also did not finally decide that underlying rights question. Those legal questions remain unresolved. The Ontario decision in R. v. Plain came after the original Nova Scotia Provincial Court ruling in R. v. Marshall, but before the Nova Scotia Supreme Court overturned Marshall’s convictions. Although the two cases concern Indigenous cannabis rights, we should not assume that the Plain judge relied on Marshall without evidence. The successful Marshall appeal is nevertheless an important development, demonstrating why earlier convictions should not be treated as the final word on these legal questions. I believe it is important that rights arguments be heard fairly and that one community’s case not be treated as the final answer for every First Nation.
Nova Scotia’s 2026 amendments to its Cannabis Control Act are another part of the current debate. The province says they are intended to improve public health and safety and strengthen enforcement; they took effect on June 25, months after Plain was released. Concerns about testing and product safety deserve a serious response. They should lead to work on testing, clear product information, safe handling, and accountability, with Six Nations meaningfully involved in setting and enforcing standards for our community.
We should also recognize the good craft growers already working within our community. Some have spent years developing their skills and take real pride in the quality and care they put into their cannabis. Others are newer to growing and are willing to learn. Rather than treating every grower as a problem, we should be creating opportunities for experienced growers to share their knowledge, mentor those who want to improve, and help establish practical standards for safe, high-quality cannabis. That is how we strengthen our community from within. A safety concern should not be used to assume that outside governments are the only ones capable of protecting people.
The Cannabis Control Law and Regulations were established in 2021 under an earlier Elected Council. In July 2026, the 59th Elected Council repealed them and directed the Cannabis Commission to take steps toward dissolution. Council cited challenges with resources and enforcement, as well as community feedback. That local decision changed the
community’s regulatory framework; it did not, by itself, settle treaty rights or remove the federal and provincial laws that courts may apply.
Is this about safety, or protecting the regulated market?
Ontario’s October 19, 2026 announcement about proposed enforcement powers raises another question that deserves an honest answer. The province estimates that approximately 30 per cent of cannabis sales in Ontario take place through illegal retailers. That estimate is for the entire unlicensed market, not specifically for stores on First Nations reserves. The province also says its proposals are meant to protect consumers and young people and create fairer competition for its roughly 1,800 authorized retailers.
That means the economic argument is not something critics have invented. It appears in the government’s own explanation. Licensed stores face licensing obligations, compliance expenses, and regulated supply requirements. Stores operating outside that system do not carry those same provincial obligations. I understand why licensed retailers would raise concerns about that difference. But I also belie it is fair to ask whether protecting the existing retail system is being given as much weight as protecting patients and consumers.
If the issue is product safety, why not discuss practical ways for Six Nations businesses and community institutions to arrange independent testing, transparent labelling, responsible sales, and patient education? If the issue is lost market share, governments should say so plainly, rather than allowing those two questions to become confused. And if Indigenous self-determination is part of the dispute, it deserves direct engagement, not simply an assumption that the provincial licensing model must be the only possible answer.
None of this proves that every product sold outside the licensed system is safe. Nor does it mean that every licensed product or business is beyond criticism. Testing, accurate strength information, age safeguards, and accountability matter. The discussion should be about how to achieve those things with our community, rather than treating enforcement and provincial control as the whole solution.
Reserve lands and dispensaries in Ontario cities are not the same question
I also believe we need to distinguish cannabis businesses operating on First Nations reserve lands from Indigenous-owned or Indigenous-identified dispensaries operating in Ontario cities outside reserve lands. In my opinion, much of the competition that concerns licensed urban retailers may be coming from storefronts in those same cities. That is a concern worth investigating, not a proven breakdown of Ontario’s estimated 30 per cent unlicensed market.
There is evidence that licensed retailers have complained specifically about unlicensed city storefronts. That does not establish how much of their lost business comes from urban stores compared with stores on reserves. And being Indigenous-owned does not, by itself, settle the legal authority to operate off reserve. But neither should complaints about off-reserve storefronts automatically become an argument for imposing provincial control over businesses on Six Nations land.
Who chose the costs of legalization?
When governments designed recreational legalization, they chose a system of provincial retail licensing, compliance requirements, regulated supply chains, and associated costs. Licensed operators have legitimate reasons to ask for consistent rules in the market they joined. Yet governments also bear responsibility for the structure and costs of that system. It should not be assumed that First Nations must surrender their claims to self-government because another business finds that system expensive.
The federal Cannabis Act review itself acknowledged that some First Nations consider provincial licensing costly and that existing agreements may provide too little incentive for Indigenous participation. This makes the debate larger than a simple choice between safety and illegality: it is also about whether governments have made meaningful room for Indigenous jurisdiction.
Ontario has openly said its proposed enforcement changes are meant both to protect consumers and to support fair competition for licensed retailers. Those are different objectives. Safety concerns deserve evidence-based responses, including independent testing, accurate labelling, age protections and accountability. Commercial competition deserves a separate, transparent discussion. Neither question should be used to bypass the discussion of First Nations rights and authority on reserve lands.
My position is not that every dispensary is automatically safe, or that the courts have already recognized an unrestricted right to sell cannabis. It is that Six Nations should be able to establish and enforce its own responsible framework for medical and recreational cannabis on our lands, and that government should engage with our community rather than treating provincial licensing as the only acceptable model.
Patients should remain at the centre
The medical cannabis discussion can get lost between government policy, commercial interests, and arguments about jurisdiction. Patients should not disappear from it. People who rely on cannabis for medical reasons deserve respect, good information, and a voice in decisions that affect their access.
I believe Six Nations should be able to pursue a locally led approach to both medical cannabis and recreational dispensaries that reflects our rights and responsibilities, while keeping patients and public safety central. That path should be built through honest discussion, community accountability, and a serious commitment to patient safety. Our community should have the space to decide what serves our people—and the responsibility to make those decisions carefully.
There is a big difference between protecting public health and protecting a government’s control over an industry. If Ontario genuinely wants safer cannabis, why not work with Six Nations to support independent testing, education, and community-led enforcement? Why must the solution always involve provincial licensing, provincial fees, and provincial authority? Our people should not have to give up control over our own lands simply to prove that we care about public safety.
The Government Owes Six Nations an Explanation
Before the Ontario government tells Six Nations that provincial regulation will make our community safer, I believe it owes our people some answers.
Where is the documented evidence of serious public-health problems involving cannabis dispensaries on Six Nations?
If those problems exist, identify them. Let our community examine the evidence and decide how best to address them.
We’ve seen federally licensed cannabis producers involved in serious safety incidents, including Organigram’s 2016–2017 cannabis recalls following the detection of unauthorized pest-control chemicals, including myclobutanil (a fungicide used against powdery mildew) and bifenazate (an insecticide), as well as the separate Legionnaires’ disease outbreak linked to its cooling towers.
Government licensing didn’t prevent those incidents. So why should our people believe that provincial approval automatically guarantees safer cannabis?
And if the government’s concerns are partly about protecting licensed businesses, collecting taxes, and maintaining control over the cannabis market, then let’s have that conversation openly instead of presenting everything as a public-safety emergency.
I am not against regulation. I am against the assumption that Indigenous people need another government to regulate us because we cannot be trusted to protect our own communities.
Six Nations people have the knowledge, experience, and ability to establish responsible standards, investigate legitimate complaints, and hold businesses accountable.
Our inherent rights and responsibilities do not disappear simply because Ontario has created a cannabis licensing system.
Our people should govern our own people. And our community’s safety should never be used as an excuse to undermine that right.
— Lindia Fazio
Background sources
- Six Nations announcement on repealing the Cannabis Control Law and Regulations, July 9, 2026
- R. v. Plain, 2026 ONSC 63
- R. v. Marshall et al., 2024 NSPC 33, discussed by Mi’kmaq Rights Association
- R. v. Marshall, 2026 NSSC 332, reported by the Mi’kmaq Rights Association
- Ontario announcement on proposed cannabis enforcement changes, October 19, 2026
- Ontario Cannabis Control Act, 2017
- Nova Scotia’s 2026 Cannabis Control Act amendments
- Canada’s Cannabis Act
- Health Canada expert panel on the Cannabis Act: Indigenous participation and licensing costs
- CityNews reporting on unlicensed cannabis storefronts in Toronto, October 29, 2026

