Archival shirt from the Chillin’ on the Grand 2014 fundraiser.

How Patients Fought for Medical Cannabis Access in Canada

Written by Lindia Fazio

Many people believe cannabis simply became legal overnight in Canada. What many do not realize is how much of that road was paved by medical patients, their families, and the people who stood beside them. Long before recreational legalization, patients were fighting in court for the right to use cannabis as medicine, to grow it themselves and to use it in the forms that helped them.

My husband and I were part of that fight. We have both been authorized to grow our own medical cannabis since 2005, beginning under the Marihuana Medical Access Regulations, or MMAR. We remember what it took to get access, and what it felt like when the government later tried to take away our ability to grow.

This history matters to us because we lived through it. We knew the patients, helped raise money for the court fight, and saw how much difference people could make when they worked together.

A doctor willing to listen and learn

When my husband first asked our doctor about signing his medical cannabis paperwork, the doctor told him to “get in line.” He had about 200 other patients asking him the same thing. That was when he explained that, when he went to medical school, doctors were not taught about cannabis and the endocannabinoid system.

Our doctor was frustrated. He complained that the federal government had thrown responsibility for medical cannabis into doctors’ laps without giving them the education to understand how it could help patients.

My husband proposed a deal: if he taught the doctor everything he knew about cannabis and the endocannabinoid system, would the doctor sign his permit? The doctor agreed.

My husband then spent months helping him learn. He visited in the evenings, shared information, and talked with him about cannabis, the endocannabinoid system, and how patients were using it. It took time, questions, and a willingness on both sides to keep talking.

Eventually, our doctor signed my husband’s authorization. He signed mine as well, and went on to help many of the other patients who had been waiting. Some of those patients later thanked my husband for helping the doctor understand.

Our doctor cared about his patients. He stayed open late, sometimes until midnight, so people who worked during the day could still see him. He continued helping people until he passed away.

We have never forgotten him. A medical cannabis program meant very little to a patient who could not find a doctor willing to sign. His willingness to listen and learn opened that door for us and for others.

Medical access came because patients fought for it

The federal government did not simply hand patients a medical cannabis program. Patients went to court because they needed a lawful way to obtain their medicine.

In 2000, the Ontario Court of Appeal’s decision in R. v. Parker helped force that change. The MMAR followed in 2001, allowing authorized patients to grow their own cannabis, have a designated person grow it, or obtain government supply. [1]

Patients needed a way to get their medicine without being left to make underground deals or risk criminal charges. The MMAR was a beginning, but there were problems with the program, and further court challenges brought changes over the years.

For those of us who entered the program, growing our medicine meant learning, investing in equipment, and taking responsibility for our supply. My husband and I have been doing that since 2005. We learned what worked for us and how to grow the cannabis we relied on.

Then, after patients had spent years building their gardens and their knowledge, the government decided to change the rules.

Standing together to protect our gardens

The Marihuana for Medical Purposes Regulations, or MMPR, were introduced in 2013. The planned transition would end personal and designated growing under the MMAR in 2014 and require patients to obtain their cannabis through commercial licensed producers. [2]

For patients who depended on growing their own medicine, the consequences were serious. As we remember it, most medical cannabis patients at the time were receiving some form of social assistance, such as ODSP. The prices patients were being quoted to purchase their medicine from licensed producers were beyond what many could afford. Being allowed to buy cannabis meant very little if you did not have the money to pay for the amount you needed.

What were those patients supposed to do if they lost the right to grow? What happened to the equipment they had purchased, the gardens they had built, and the years they had spent learning to meet their own medical needs?

My husband and I joined the MMRA Coalition Against Repeal. We were part of the coalition bringing the federal government to court to protect patients’ access, in the fight that became Allard v. Canada.

Through that work, we connected with other patients and advocates, the YouTube channel, and the Cannabis in Canada support group. People shared information, supported one another, and helped raise the money needed to keep the legal fight going.

We helped with coalition fundraising because the outcome would affect patients across the country, including us. Many people stood to lose the way they had been legally producing their medicine.

Chillin’ on the Grand: Six Nations showed up

In 2014, we organized Chillin’ on the Grand on Six Nations to help fund the legal battle. About 350 patients, supporters, and activists came together. That one event raised more than $40,000.

We were proud of what our community helped accomplish. A court challenge takes money, and every person who attended, donated, or helped organize contributed to keeping that fight alive. We also helped with other coalition fundraising efforts.

We still have the event shirt. The front carries Chillin’ on the Grand 2014, and the back carries an advertisement for Paradise Gardens Hydroponics, the shop I own, showing its support. Looking at it brings back the people and the work behind that day.

Front of the Chillin’ on the Grand 2014 shirt: Together we will save our gardens.
Back of the event shirt showing Paradise Gardens Hydroponics and Headshop’s support.

A court judgment records the legal outcome. That shirt reminds us of the community effort that helped make it possible.

The injunction gave patients protection

In March 2014, the coalition’s legal fight secured an injunction protecting qualifying former MMAR patients while the case continued. Eligible patients could keep growing under the protected terms of their earlier authorizations. [2, 3]

Those gardens could stay standing. Patients covered by the order could continue producing their medicine while the larger challenge worked its way through court.

These are the patients we refer to as being grandfathered in. The protection applied to people who met the injunction’s conditions and depended on the terms of their authorizations. [3, 4]

As Allard lawyer John Conroy explained in his April 2017 update, qualifying patients’ original authorizations and production licences continued at the specified locations and amounts despite their printed expiry dates, until the court ordered otherwise. For patients remaining within those protected terms, continuing under the injunction did not require getting a new doctor’s signature every year to renew those old documents. Changes to the protected arrangements could require an application under the newer system. That distinction mattered deeply to people who had struggled to find a doctor in the first place. [6]

In February 2016, the Federal Court ruled that the MMPR failed to provide reasonable access to medical cannabis and violated patients’ Charter rights. Affordability was part of that constitutional finding: forcing patients to rely on licensed producers could leave them choosing between their medicine and other basic necessities. The court found that this restriction was not justified by the government’s stated objectives. This was a question of whether patients could actually obtain the medicine they needed, not simply whether they were legally allowed to buy it. [7]

The Access to Cannabis for Medical Purposes Regulations, or ACMPR, followed in August 2016, providing a registration route for patients to grow for themselves or use a designated grower. [1, 4]

Patients had stood together, challenged the government, and helped protect something essential to their lives. We were proud to have been part of that effort.

Patients also fought for more than dried cannabis

The fight for medical access also included extracts, edibles and concentrates. Patients needed to be able to use their medicine in forms suited to their needs.

Our coalition supported the fight associated with Ted Smith and the case involving Owen Smith, which reached the Supreme Court of Canada as R. v. Smith.

In June 2015, the Supreme Court ruled that restricting medical access to dried cannabis was unconstitutional. The decision protected authorized patients’ ability to use and make other cannabis preparations for their own medical purposes. [5]

For patients who could not or did not want to inhale cannabis, that mattered enormously. Their medical needs did not disappear because the rules recognized only dried flower.

These changes came from people willing to challenge those rules and the supporters who helped them carry the cases forward. Our coalition supported that work too.

Bringing that experience to Six Nations

As a Six Nations member, I care deeply about our inherent rights and our community’s ability to make decisions for itself. Patient education is part of what I want to contribute. To me, standing up for our rights also means helping people in our community have the knowledge to make informed choices about their medicine.

Whether someone is new to cannabis or has used it for years, they should have a place to ask questions about preparing their medicine and using it carefully, without hurting themselves or others. That is why this work matters to me personally, and why my husband and I have continued sharing what we have learned.

My husband and I also attended every cannabis community consultation meeting organized by Band Council. We listened to what people in our community had to say about whether Six Nations wanted a cannabis industry, and we tried to speak when we had the opportunity.

We proposed a plan to Band Council that brought cannabis education and industry together. We wanted the knowledge gained by patients and people already working in the community to be part of those discussions.

We were also supposed to make a presentation to Council. As we remember it, Seven Leaf got in ahead of us, and the meeting where we were to present was cancelled. We never had the opportunity we had expected to explain our proposal at that meeting.

For us, education belonged in the conversation from the beginning. People needed somewhere to ask questions about their medicine, different preparations and how to use them carefully. Our experience as patients, growers and advocates was something we wanted to contribute.

Passing the knowledge on

Our experience with the doctor showed us how much could change when someone had access to information and a place to ask questions. We carried that belief into Paradise Compassion Club, which we began in 2012.

Before COVID stopped the gatherings, our education meetings brought in more than 100 people. We talked about medical and recreational cannabis, making different preparations and understanding how to use them more safely. We encouraged people to start low and go slowly.

People came with questions, and they brought their own experiences. Some were new to cannabis. Others had used it for years but wanted to understand more. Those conversations mattered to us.

I have owned Paradise Gardens Hydroponics since 1992 and have spent years teaching people in our Six Nations community about growing plants and indoor hydroponics. For some people with disabilities, growing without the need to handle heavy soil, bushels and wheelbarrows can make gardening more accessible.

My husband’s own experience is part of why we listen carefully to what patients tell us. He describes cannabis as putting his pain “at the back of his head.” It does not take the pain away in the same way his pain medication does, but it can help him stop concentrating on it so much—almost as though he can forget about it for a while. That is his personal experience, rather than a promise about what someone else will feel.

Helping people learn has been part of our lives for a long time. It connects the evenings my husband spent with our doctor, the coalition work, our community meetings and the questions people still bring to us.

Remembering how we got here

When people talk about cannabis becoming legal, I hope they remember the medical patients who helped make change possible.

We remember the people waiting for a doctor’s signature. We remember our doctor staying open late and being willing to learn. We remember patients worrying about losing their gardens, and a community on Six Nations coming together to help pay for a court fight that reached far beyond our own homes.

My husband and I have both been growing our own medical cannabis since 2005. We joined the coalition, helped raise money and supported the fight to protect patients’ access because it affected our lives and the lives of people we knew.

We are proud of that history, and grateful to everyone who stood together through it. The ability to grow our medicine, and to use it in forms that meet patients’ needs, carries years of work and sacrifice behind it.

That is the story we want people to remember when they think cannabis simply became legal overnight.

Quality • Care • Community

Historical sources

1. Health Canada, Understanding the Access to Cannabis for Medical Purposes Regulations.

2. Federal Court, March 21, 2014 injunction order, 2014 FC 280.

3. Health Canada, Information for Law Enforcement — Medical Use of Cannabis, section on the MMAR injunction.

4. Canada Gazette, ACMPR and Regulatory Impact Analysis, August 24, 2016.

5. Health Canada, Medical cannabis annual compliance and enforcement report, 2015–2016, discussion of R. v. Smith.

6. John W. Conroy, MMAR constitutional challenge updates, April 2017 and August 27, 2016, explaining continued protection under the injunction and changes requiring an application under the ACMPR.

7. Federal Courts Reports, Allard v. Canada, 2016 FC 236, discussion of affordability, basic necessities and section 7 of the Charter.

Leave a Comment